Best Online Trading Card Shop

FREE SHIPPING OVER $200 ON ALL ORDERS

The Top 10 2026 NFL Prospects Most Likely to Go in the First Round

  • by Alex Judge
  • 4 min read

The Highlights

The best prospects of the year include:

  • Fernando Mendoza (QB)
  • Jeremiyah Love (RB)
  • Arvell Reese (LB/Edge)
  • David Bailey (Edge)
  • Sonny Styles (LB)
  • Carnell Tate (WR)
  • Rueben Bain Jr. (Edge)
  • Caleb Downs (S)
  • Mansoor Delane (CB)
  • Kadyn Proctor (OT)


The 2026 NFL Draft rankings feature some of the most intriguing potential picks we’ve seen in a while. There’s no doubt these players will make for an unforgettable season of football, but for the real collectors out there? The game begins right now, pre-draft.

Learn all about the best 2026 NFL prospect rankings and find out which sports card singles you should focus on this year with our sports card blog.

The Top 10 2026 NFL Prospects

#1: Fernando Mendoza (QB)

Indiana’s most popular QB is a near-unanimous choice for first pick in the draft, even by trusted NFL analysts like Daniel Jeremiah. What makes Mendoza such a compelling choice this year?

For starters, he’s coming off a Heisman trophy win and shows remarkable agility considering how early he is in his career. He can hang well in the pocket and tank hits to hunt big plays like it’s nothing. If we’re measuring value in terms of great decision-making and resilience, Mendoza is the top choice of the year.

#2: Jeremiyah Love (RB)

This 2026 NFL prospect comes from the hallowed RB-producing institution that is Notre Dame. True to that reputation, he’s already a proven dynamic threat on the field as a runner and receiver. As a leader in our 2026 NFL Draft rankings, he can steal the ball effortlessly and beat defenders without seeming to slowing down at all.

If the hype around RBs in football card boxes is any indication, we’re already living in an era where versatile backs can make the game. Jeremiyah Love is well on his way to building the playbook for his prospective team and joining the greats.

Football stadium filled with spectators

#3: Arvell Reese (LB/Edge)

Ohio State’s defensive machine does not stop, and this 2026 NFL prospect is proof. The versatile edge/linebacker hybrid is a frequent top-3 name on big boards, and he’s going to remain a quick pick as we head into the draft.

If you’re building a collection around athletic rushers who can generate power as well, Reese is a natural pick.

#4: David Bailey (Edge)

David Bailey’s record is nothing short of impressive, even if we’re just looking at his performance for Texas Tech. He projects as an instant impact bookend for most defensive lines in the league, and teams desperate for sack production will be eager to swoop this 2026 NFL prospect quickly.

#5: Sonny Styles (LB)

Our 2026 NFL Draft rankings aren’t quite done with Ohio State yet! Styles’s NFL Scouting Combine performance was enough to put him near the top of most 2026 NFL prospect rankings. The former safety player can run elite times with the best of the league, and his coverage skills are absolutely top-tier.

If Styles can maintain the results he delivered in the Big Ten title game, he’s going to be one of the best LBs in the league.

#6: Carnell Tate (WR)

Carnell Tate is the clear WR1 if we’re comparing elite 2026 NFL prospects. If you’re a collector looking to pre-order cards and secure the best rookies early, we recommend keeping an eye out for this WR. Why?

Tate’s 78 production score is pretty incredible for rookie route-runners in the league, despite a modest 4.53 40-yard dash. Many teams are going to need a reliable receiver in the new season, and Tate’s a great choice for the role.

#7: Rueben Bain Jr. (Edge)

Many of our picks for the best 2026 NFL prospects so far have focused largely on faster, more agile players who can produce impactful plays. Bain Jr. breaks that mold somewhat as a thick square edge rusher. His explosive get-off and production make him a clear steal for most teams, and he’s a no-brainer for any 2026 NFL Draft ranking.

#8: Caleb Downs (S)

It’s another Buckeye! When it comes to premier safeties in this year’s draft class, Downs is in a league of his own. He shows elite range and playmaking ability even in a draft that is heavy on defensive backs.

This 2026 NFL prospect will be a prized pick for his ability to pick the right angles and consistency on the field.

#9: Mansoor Delane (CB)

We can’t mention consistency and not bring up LSU’s leading CB this year. Delane is incredibly smooth in coverage and can be physical at the catch point when required, making him a frequent top 10 pick on most boards. Teams tend to prioritize shutdown corners in pass-heavy leagues, and Delane’s CB abilities could give him a fast draft this year.

#10: Kadyn Proctor (OT)

This 2026 NFL prospect’s massive, imposing frame has helped him build an early reputation as one of the best young tacklers on the green. As the top OT in our 2026 NFL prospect rankings, he offers a real dual threat that most teams can’t ignore:

  • He’s a veritable powerhouse in the run game, without compromising on maneuverability.
  • He has also been used well as a wide receiver and RB, demonstrating versatility.

Collect The Best of Our 2026 NFL Draft Ranking!

All set for the new NFL season? Pull the year’s most promising rookie autos with a trading card store that gives you free shipping on US orders over $200, helps you save with an incredible rewards program, and delivers faster than you can throw a football. Lock your order in at Skybox Collectibles today!

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best 2026 NFL prospects?

Fernando Mendoza (QB), Jeremiyah Love (RB), and Arvell Reese (LB/Edge) are among the best prospects of the year, but only time will tell whether they can deliver on their potential!

Which position group dominates the 2026 NFL Draft class?

Defensive positions are very dominant this year compared to 2025 football. Ohio State’s defensive players, for example, are everywhere in most top-10 discussions this year.

Is it worth collecting 2026 NFL prospects?

Yes! Most prospect classes feature at least one star player who goes on to build an incredible legacy, and that comes with soaring card values. The earliest rookie cards are often the most affordable, giving you the best possible ROI as a collector.

Alex Judge

Alex Judge

Position: Store Manager

Email: alexj@skyboxct.com

Alex is a passionate collector who specializes in Pokemon, Magic The Gathering, Baseball cards and Football cards. He has been collecting trading cards, and has been involved with sports most of his life and wants to bring a positive influence to the industry.

Search